Slice Guide to Boston Pizza by Neighborhood
Boston’s neighborhoods each bring a slightly different personality to pizza. Some spots lean traditional, others push toppings in new directions, and many balance both. This guide keeps it simple: where to go, what to order, and how to get there by MBTA. Updated August 2025.
At-a-Glance
- Neighborhoods: North End, South End, South Boston, East Boston, Back Bay, Fenway, Allston/Brighton, Jamaica Plain, Dorchester
- MBTA stops: Haymarket, Back Bay, Broadway, Maverick, Hynes, Kenmore, Harvard Ave, Stony Brook, Fields Corner
- Price tiers: $, $$, $$$
- Wait/Resy notes: North End waits peak Fri–Sat; South End takes Resy; others walk-in friendly
- Dietary tags: Gluten-free at select spots; vegan-friendly in JP and Allston
- Hours/late-night: Many open until 11; Allston/Brighton and Fenway run later
North End — Regina Pizzeria
Regina has anchored the North End since 1926, and its coal-fired pies remain a steady draw. Expect a chewy, charred crust, tangy sauce, and a lively room that still feels old Boston. Go early or late to skip the long lines, and plan on pitchers and pies as the easy move.
Price: $ (~$15 per pie)
MBTA/Parking: Haymarket (Green/Orange)
Accessibility: Narrow doorway, small restrooms
Link: reginapizzeria.com
South End — Picco
Picco balances crisp thin-crust pizzas with a small but thoughtful beer list and its own ice cream counter. The pies come out blistered and light, and the pepperoni with hot honey has a loyal following. Weekends fill up, so book ahead; midweek nights are relaxed and easy. Families often land here because dessert is built-in.
Price: $$ (~$20–25 pp)
MBTA/Parking: Back Bay (Orange/Commuter Rail)
Accessibility: Step-free entry, tight tables
Link: piccorestaurant.com
South Boston — Capo
On West Broadway, Capo turns out Neapolitan-style pizzas alongside a full Italian menu. The Margherita is simple and solid, while seasonal pies bring new flavors. It works well for groups with mixed cravings, since the pasta program is strong too. Reservations make sense on weekends; weekday bar seats are often open.
Price: $$ (~$22–28 pp)
MBTA/Parking: Broadway (Red Line)
Accessibility: Ramp entrance, accessible restrooms
Link: caposouthboston.com
East Boston — Santarpio’s
Santarpio’s is straightforward: cash only, paper plates, and thin-crust pies that define Eastie comfort food. The sausage and garlic pizza is the standard order, and the room is noisy in a good way. Expect a line at peak hours but quick turnover once you’re inside.
Price: $ (~$15–20 per pie)
MBTA/Parking: Maverick (Blue Line)
Accessibility: Narrow step at entrance, no dedicated restroom
Link: santarpiospizza.com
Back Bay — Eataly Pizza & Pasta
Inside Prudential Center, Eataly serves Roman-style pizza with crisp crusts and clean toppings. It’s reliable for a quick lunch, a pre-Fenway bite, or a group meal when not everyone wants pizza. Slices are quick, tables run busier, but turnover is steady.
Price: $$ (~$20–25 pp)
MBTA/Parking: Hynes (Green Line)
Accessibility: Full ADA access
Link: eataly.com
Fenway — Tasty Burger Pizza Nights
Tasty Burger isn’t a pizza shop first, but its late-night slices keep Fenway crowds happy after games. The pies are simple, the service is quick, and the vibe is casual. It’s a dependable option when you need food after 11 p.m. without much fuss.
Price: $ (~$5–6 per slice)
MBTA/Parking: Kenmore (Green Line)
Accessibility: Step-free entrance, casual seating
Link: tastyburger.com
Allston/Brighton — Otto Pizza
Otto brought Portland’s mix-and-match topping style to Harvard Ave, and its slices have become a neighborhood standard. The mashed potato, bacon, and scallion pie is surprisingly balanced, and vegan-friendly options broaden the appeal. Hours stretch later than most, making it a strong late-night stop.
Price: $ (~$5–6 per slice; $20–25 per pie)
MBTA/Parking: Harvard Ave (Green Line B)
Accessibility: Narrow but step-free entry
Link: ottoportland.com
Jamaica Plain — Same Old Place
Same Old Place keeps Greek-style pan pizza alive in JP with thick, cheesy pies that have been on order sheets for decades. It’s neighborhood food at its core, reliable for delivery and casual dine-in alike. Calzones and subs round out the comfort-heavy menu.
Price: $ (~$15–20 per pie)
MBTA/Parking: Stony Brook (Orange Line)
Accessibility: Street-level entry, limited seating
Link: sameoldplacepizza.com
Dorchester — Molinari’s Pizzeria
Dorchester Center’s Molinari’s keeps things simple in the best way: thin crust, wood-fired pies made from fresh ingredients in a cozy open-kitchen setting. It’s a sit-down spot with a warm neighborhood feel and dependable flavor—a good replacement for the defunct Venice Pizza.
Price: Moderate
MBTA/Parking: Near Adams St/Lower Mills (Red Line); street parking available
Accessibility: Casual interior; check for accessibility details
Link: molinarispizzeria.com
